AI visibility tools compared: what they measure and what they cannot

Peec AI, Profound, Semrush and Surfer all track AI-assistant visibility. What each actually measures, how reliable the methodology is, and whether you need one yet.

Published ·4 min read·5 sources cited

The short version

  • Every tool in this category works the same way: run a sample of prompts on a schedule and record what comes back. There is no first-party data source.
  • Bundled options — Semrush and Surfer — are the cheapest entry if you already pay for them.
  • Dedicated tools like Peec AI and Profound go deeper; neither publishes machine-readable pricing.
  • All of them measure. None changes the pages that determine whether you get mentioned.

This is the newest tool category in SEO and the one where the gap between what is claimed and what is happening under the hood is widest. Before paying for one, it helps to know exactly what the thing is doing.

There is no equivalent of Search Console for AI assistants. No vendor provides first-party data on how often you are mentioned. So every tool in this category samples: it runs a set of prompts against a set of assistants on a schedule, records which brands and sources appear, and reports trends. That is a reasonable methodology, and it is sampling rather than measurement.

The options

AI visibility tooling
ToolPlanPriceWhat you get
Peec AIpeec.ai · read 2026-09-18Vendor does not publish machine-readable pricing for this product.—Not published—
Profoundtryprofound.com · read 2026-09-18Vendor does not publish machine-readable pricing for this product.—Not published—
Surfer SEOsurferseo.com · read 2026-09-18Discovery$49/mo120 documents/mo · 1 seat
AI Search Analytics$82/moAI visibility across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google and Gemini · 50 prompts daily
Standard$99/mo360 documents/mo · 3 seats · 25 AI prompts weekly
Pro$182/mo360 documents/mo · 5 seats · 50 prompts daily
Peace of Mind$299/moUnlimited documents under fair use · 10 seats · API
Enterprise$999/moCustom limits · white-label

Neither Peec AI nor Profound publishes plan prices in a machine-readable form, so we have not quoted figures we could not read. Surfer’s AI Search Analytics plan is priced at $82/mo billed annually. Semrush includes AI-visibility features within its platform plans.

Bundled: Semrush and Surfer

If you already pay for either, check what you have before buying anything dedicated. Semrush has pushed AI-visibility tracking into the core platform; Surfer sells an AI Search Analytics plan at $82/mo annually and includes prompt allowances on its content tiers. For most teams this is sufficient and marginal cost is zero or low.

Dedicated: Peec AI and Profound

Peec AI is purpose-built for answer engines, with prompt-level reporting showing which questions you surface for and competitor share of voice. Profound targets enterprise reporting, including which sources assistants draw on when describing your category — useful for comms teams as well as SEO. Both require a sales conversation to price.

The free proxy

Branded search volume in Search Console. If assistants are recommending you, some of those people will search your name afterwards. It is indirect and confounded by everything else you do, and it costs nothing. For many businesses it is enough to know whether something is happening before paying to measure it precisely.

What to ask before buying

  1. How many prompts, how often, from where? Sample size and frequency determine how much noise you are looking at.
  2. Which assistants and which model versions? Results vary between products and shift with model updates.
  3. Does it distinguish mention from citation? Being named and being linked are different outcomes.
  4. What will we do differently based on this? If the answer is "nothing yet", buy the capability to act first.
  5. Have we fixed our entity description? Measuring a problem you have not addressed is expensive telemetry.

Before committing to any of them, consider running the measurement manually for a month. Write down twenty prompts a customer might plausibly ask, run them against two or three assistants on the same day each week, and record whether you appear. It is tedious and it costs nothing, and it usually tells you within a month whether there is enough signal to justify automating the process.

Treat the numbers as directional

Prompt phrasing, region, timing and model version all change results. A visibility score that moves 15% month on month may reflect a model update rather than anything you did. These tools are useful for trend over quarters, not for attributing a change to a specific action.

What our own tool does and does not do here

We do not sell AI-visibility tracking and have no reporting dashboard for it. We work on the implementation side — entity clarity, structured data, extractable answers. If you want to measure AI visibility, buy one of the tools above; we are not an alternative.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best AI visibility tool?

If you already pay for Semrush or Surfer, start with what you have. Dedicated tools like Peec AI and Profound go deeper but require a sales conversation to price.

How do these tools actually work?

They run a sample of prompts against assistants on a schedule and record which brands and sources appear. There is no first-party data source, so everything is sampled.

Do I need an AI visibility tool?

Only if AI visibility is a channel you are accountable for reporting on, and only after you have addressed the on-site work that determines whether you get mentioned.

Is there a free way to track AI visibility?

Not directly. Branded search volume in Search Console is an imperfect free proxy — if assistants recommend you, some people search your name afterwards.

Sources

Every figure on this page traces to one of these. Dates are when we last read the page — pricing and features change, so treat anything older than a few months as a starting point rather than gospel. All outbound links here are nofollow.

  1. [1]
    Semrush Pricing and Plans

    Semrush · semrush.com · Vendor page · read 2026-09-18

  2. [2]
    Surfer SEO Pricing

    Surfer · surferseo.com · Vendor page · read 2026-09-18

  3. [3]
    Peec AI Pricing

    Peec AI · peec.ai · Vendor page · read 2026-09-18

    Plan tiers are listed but prices are not published in a machine-readable form.

  4. [4]
    Profound — Answer Engine Insights

    Profound · tryprofound.com · Vendor page · read 2026-09-18

  5. [5]
    Google Search Console

    Google · search.google.com · Vendor page · read 2026-09-18

Keep reading

This is the newest tool category in SEO and the one where the gap between what is claimed and what is happening under the hood is widest. Before paying for one, it helps to know exactly what the thin…